Jump label: Textanfang, Navigation.

Sahra Wagenknecht

Sahra Wagenknecht
Language selection

October 22nd, 2008

The EU Council appears badly informed

Sahra Wagenknecht on the answer by the EU Council to the written question raised by her on 29 August 2008 concerning the activities of Estonian "volunteers" in the war in Georgia

"The Council is not aware of the case in question", this is the short answer given by the EU Council to the question I tabled in August on the initiatives of Estonian so-called volunteers in the war in Georgia. Should this answer be correct one would wonder what it is the Council is aware of at all. After all the call to send off Estonian volunteers with uniforms to a war is not a petty item but a highly controversial matter.

However, it can hardly be imagined that the Council is unaware of the initiative started by the Estonian Reserve Officers´Association with its call for volunteers to take part in the war in Georgia. After all the initiative was widely discussed in the media in Estonia and beyond. That the EU Council in its succinct one-line-answer nonetheless chooses to go about in the manner of the three wise monkeys who hear no evil, see no evil and speak no evil, clearly supports the conclusion that things are heated up behind the scenes making it advisable for the Council not to take sides in this matter.

Here the questions that I asked:

Written question P-4782/08 by Sahra Wagenknecht (GUE/NGL) to the Council

Activities of Estonian 'volunteers' during the war in Georgia

Soon after the start of the military confrontation between Georgia and Russia, which was caused by the Georgian attack on the town of Zchinwali in South Ossetia, there was a call from the Estonian Reserve Officers' Association for volunteers to be recruited for a mission to support Georgia in the war against Russia and also for uniforms to be worn on the mission. It was announced that the volunteers would be transported in a government plane which was to take humanitarian aid to Tbilisi and fly Estonian citizens out of Georgia. The call came, among others, from Priit Heinsalu, chair of the Estonian Reserve Officers' Association, and Indrek Tarand, former diplomat and now director of the Laidon Museum. Some 50 people answered the call and flew to Tbilisi, although media reports stated that they did not fly in a government plane. The volunteers are said to have included members of the Estonian paramilitary armed forces, the Kaitseliit, as well as Estonian reservists.

1. What does the Council know about this initiative involving Estonian volunteers? Does the Council know whether members of the Estonian armed forces or official Estonian security forces took part in this initiative, and if so, how many? Does the Council know whether any participants in this initiative are still in Georgia?

2. As far as the Council is aware, did any Estonian citizens take part in the fighting between Georgia and Russia?

3. What does the Council think of the fact that the call to take part in this initiative was made by former members of the Estonian armed forces and government?

4. Has this initiative featured in discussions between the Council and the Estonian Government, and if so, what did this involve?

5. Does the Council consider initiatives involving the sending of volunteers from a Member State to a conflict zone to be a suitable way of helping to reach a peaceful solution? If not, what measures has the Council taken in order to prevent such initiatives in the future?


Überarbeitete und aktualisierte Neuausgabe:

Freiheit statt Kapitalismus.
Über vergessene Ideale, die Eurokrise und unsere Zukunft

Erschienen im Campus-Verlag

  • Nachdenkseiten

Aktuelles und Hinweise

  • Mitmachen!


Jump label: Page top, Textanfang, Navigation.